Just-in-Time Interfaces and the Threat of Perfect Competition
How AI Agents Are Dissolving Web Friction—and Brand Margins Along with It
Forget the Sci-Fi. The Real Shift Is Structural.
When we talk about AI in commerce, the industry gravitates toward sci-fi visions. You say "Book a two-week honeymoon to Japan," and the AI coordinates flights, hotels, and dinner reservations behind the scenes.
That future is coming. But what's actually happening in the agentic economy right now is more structural—and more disruptive. The shift isn't about booking vacations. It's about rethinking how we interact with the internet.
We're leaving behind tedious, static web forms for the "Just-in-Time" interface. But as we remove friction and hand purchasing over to algorithms, we're heading straight for a problem every consumer brand should worry about: the threat of perfect competition.
If you've been following our coverage of how Rufus auto-buy actually works or the retail strategies emerging to counter it, you know the agents are already here. This piece is about what happens to the market once they take over.
Level One: The Rise of "Just-in-Time" UI
From Web Forms to Invisible Checkout
For twenty years, digital commerce has been built around human constraints. Category filters, shopping carts, multi-page checkout flows, CAPTCHAs, endless form fields. It's high-friction by design—built to guide a human eye and capture user data.
AI commerce replaces these rigid hurdles with "just-in-time" (JIT) interfaces. Instead of a human navigating a site built for eyeballs and mouse clicks, an AI talks directly to the data layer, surfacing only the decisions the user needs to make, when they need to make them.
Level one is already here. An AI fills out checkout forms on your behalf using a URL.
How It Works Today
You drop a product link into your AI agent. The agent navigates to the merchant, skips the visual noise, and completes checkout using your saved preferences, shipping details, and payment credentials. For the consumer, the UI disappears. The legacy web's friction gets abstracted away entirely.
For merchants, this creates a real problem. If an agent is pinging your checkout API at superhuman speed, how do you know it's a legitimate purchase on behalf of a user—and not a bot?
We covered this in "Your Fraud System Is Blocking Revenue, Not Fraud". Legacy fraud detection assumes all non-human traffic is hostile. In a JIT world, that assumption becomes a revenue killer.
That's why the Know Your Agent (KYA) standard is becoming the trust layer for modern checkouts—letting merchants verify an agent's identity and accept automated purchases without opening the door to fraud.
But once checkout friction disappears, something deeper shifts in the market.
The Utilitarian Buyer and the Loss of "Soul"
When Algorithms Replace Emotion
When a human shops, the decision-making is messy. We're influenced by aspirational imagery, emotional copywriting, brand prestige, the aesthetic "vibe" of a retailer's website. We gladly pay premium margins for things that feel right.
AI agents don't feel. They calculate.
As shopping shifts to AI, purchasing goes perfectly utilitarian. Tell your agent to "buy the best paper towels" or "find a mid-century modern coffee table under $400," and it decides on structured data alone: dimensions, material composition, delivery speed, price per ounce, aggregated review scores.
What Humans See
- Aspirational lifestyle imagery
- Brand heritage and prestige
- Emotional copywriting
- Curated aesthetic "vibe"
What Agents See
- Dimensions and material specs
- Price per unit / ounce
- Aggregated review scores
- Delivery speed and warranty terms
That strips out the "soul" of products. Brand heritage, emotional resonance, the curated Instagram feed—invisible to an agent scraping JSON from a product page. If it can't be quantified in a data feed, it doesn't exist in an agentic marketplace.
The Brutal Reality of Perfect Competition
When Brand Loyalty Gets Optimized Away
Why does this matter? Because subjective human emotion is the bedrock of profit margins.
Strip the "soul" out and rely on measurable utility, and you push the market toward perfect competition. The economics textbook version: all buyers and sellers have perfect information, products are interchangeable. Prices get driven to marginal cost.
Brands avoided this for decades with marketing moats and brand affinity.
The Margin Collapse Scenario
Your brand sells a premium blender for $150. An agent finds a competitor's $130 blender with identical motor wattage, blade steel, and warranty terms. It picks the $130 option every time. No hesitation. No brand loyalty. No attachment to the unboxing experience.
In a utilitarian, agent-mediated market, brand loyalty gets replaced by algorithmic optimization. For CPG companies, this wipes out brand margins they've spent decades building. Commerce becomes a spec-driven race to the bottom.
Perfect competition was always a theoretical construct. AI agents are turning it into an operational reality.
Surviving the Agent Economy
Two Imperatives for Merchants and Brands
JIT interfaces are a win for consumers. The tedious Web 2.0 checkout dies. But merchants, developers, and brands have to adapt to a different economic reality.
Become the "Default Prompt"
Build loyalty so strong outside the shopping interface that humans tell their agents to skip the utilitarian math. The prompt can't just be "buy me running shoes"—it has to be "buy me Hoka running shoes."
If the human doesn't hardcode the brand into the prompt, the agent defaults to the highest-rated spec equivalent. Brand building doesn't become irrelevant in the agent economy—it becomes the only thing that prevents commoditization.
We saw this in our analysis of how Rufus handles product discovery. When an agent curates the shortlist, brands that aren't named in the prompt get filtered out before the human sees anything.
Secure the Trust Layer
Perfect competition only works if the agents executing the trades are legitimate. As agents take over the purchasing funnel, merchants need verification that tells them who the agent is, what it's allowed to do, and whether it can be trusted—fast checkouts, bad bots blocked.
We covered this in the Agent Trust Certificate framework, the verification layer for agents mirrors what SSL did for browsers: it doesn't slow down the transaction. It makes the transaction possible. Without it, merchants are left choosing between blocking all non-human traffic (and losing revenue) or accepting everything (and eating fraud).
Headless checkout APIs paired with Agent Trust Certificates let merchants accept agent purchases at speed, with accountability built into every transaction.
The Bottom Line
The agents are already shopping. The friction is disappearing. The question left is whether the economy is ready for algorithms to do the buying.
JIT interfaces erase the checkout pain that's defined online commerce for twenty years. Good for consumers. But the same force that kills friction kills the emotional cues brands rely on to justify premium pricing. The market tilts toward pure specification, pure price, pure utility.
The brands that survive will be the ones humans name in their prompts. The merchants that thrive will be the ones who can verify the agent, trust the transaction, and complete the sale before a competitor's API responds.
Ready for the JIT Economy?
When the checkout UI disappears, trust infrastructure is what's left. KYA helps merchants verify agent identity and accept automated purchases—without the fraud risk.
Request a Demo